Possible DUPEs?! ELF peachy lipliner vs Essence nude coral lipliner ..

HELLO GUYS!

I hope you're all okay and enjoying your day. 

I have a comparison post today of two products which can be possible dupes to each other.. 

but are they?? 

I am talking about 

ELF mineral lipliner in peachy

vs

Essence lip liner in nude coral

I initially purchased ELF's mineral lipliner in peachy, loved it, bought a back up.

Then I found out about Essence, and something that caught my eye was this Essence nude coral lipliner. 

Now this Essence lipliner costs like €1.03

whereas the 

ELF one costs £3. 

Anyway here's what I think. 

They might seem like possible dupes when used seperately, 

HOWEVER

A. the formula is different - ELF's is more creamy

B. packaging - ELF's a twist up lip liner

C. shade - ELF's is more coral and peachy, whereas Essence's leans more pink

D. pigmentation - ELF's is more pigmented

 so that's about it.

I wouldn't call these dupes, 

they might seem like similar products when used seperately though. 

BOTTOM LINE.

I don't really recommend the Essence lip liner 

- a bit too drying, and the ELF one looks prettier on me. 

FTC DISCLAIMER: I am not paid to do this post. I bought the product myself for my personal use unless otherwise stated and I am not affiliated with any company. Everything I said in this post is my genuine honest opinion :)